FAIR Plan Gov Involvement
What is the federal government's role in the FAIR plan? Does it subsidize rates? Does it act as a reinsurer? Or is it similar to auto residual market where all the private insurers just share the premium and loss.
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
What is the federal government's role in the FAIR plan? Does it subsidize rates? Does it act as a reinsurer? Or is it similar to auto residual market where all the private insurers just share the premium and loss.
Comments
It is true that it's a residual market where voluntary market participants share the premium and loss. FAIR plans are organized by individual states.
Federal Role in FAIR Plans:
When FAIR Plans were created in the late 1960s (after urban unrest and widespread redlining), they were encouraged by the federal government through the Urban Property Protection and Reinsurance Act of 1968.
The Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) provided reinsurance and support to states that set up FAIR Plans.
The federal government originally offered reinsurance coverage to state FAIR Plans to make them more viable. This has largely been phased out, but it helped establish the programs.
Through agencies like FEMA, the federal government affects insurance markets by how it responds to natural disasters, funds mitigation efforts, and sets policies around building codes, flood zones, and climate adaptation.
These policies can affect the risk landscape, influencing where FAIR Plans are needed or how heavily they're used.
Federal agencies like GAO (Government Accountability Office) and FEMA regularly publish reports on the growing strain on state FAIR Plans, especially with the increasing risk from climate change.
While regulation is a state matter, the federal government highlights systemic risks, influencing state and insurer behavior.
What the Federal Government Does Not Do:
It does not regulate FAIR Plans directly.
It does not fund them in most cases (outside of disaster assistance).
It does not set the rates or policies—that’s up to state insurance departments and the FAIR Plan boards.
Does the end part of this comment imply that the state governments regulate FAIR plans, fund FAIR plans, and sets the rates and policies? If the funding point is true, how is that accomplished?
Yes. Funding is through sharing premium and loss within the voluntary market.